Editorial - China Can't Have It Both Ways

April 27th 2009

New York, NY, USA, 26 April 2009 (Editorial - The New York Times) - The Chinese government issued two statements last Thursday. Both were only briefly, and separately, noted in the press. They make for a curious contrast.

In one, China denounced Japan's Prime Minister Taro Aso for making an offering to the Yasukuni shrine. This is the shrine that honors 2.5 million Japanese war dead, including 14 top war criminals from World War II, when Japan committed terrible atrocities in China.

China was furious when the then-prime minister, Junichiro Koizumi, visited Yasukuni in 2005, and the next two prime ministers stayed clear.

But Mr. Aso, a pugnacious nationalist, revived the controversy on Tuesday by offering the Shinto shrine a potted plant. Mr. Aso's spokesmen insisted that this was not the same as a visit, and in any case would not affect his scheduled visit to China next week.

China was furious, telling the Japanese that 'the question of history is highly sensitive.'

In the other statement, China demanded that the United States cancel a visit by the Dalai Lama (he arrived on Friday for a two-week tour). The Buddhist religious leader, a recipient of the Nobel peace prize who is respected around the world, says he is seeking only autonomy for his homeland, Tibet. China vilifies him as a separatist and regularly lambastes countries and leaders who receive him.

'We oppose the Dalai Lama going to any country to engage in splittist activities under any pretext,' said Jiang Yu, the same Foreign Ministry spokeswoman who had earlier found history to be so sensitive.

Mr. Aso's offering to Yasukuni was blatantly provocative and offensive, even if all he offered was a potted sakaki evergreen, and his explanation

 

Latest News

20th Shotön Opera Festival Begins
March 27th 2015
Dharamsala, HP, India, 27 March 2015 - This morning, His Holiness the Dalai Lama presided over the opening of the 20th Shotön Festival in exile. The last such celebration of Tibetan opera in Tibet took place in 1958 and the tradition was revived on His Holiness’s advice in 1993. As he drove from his residence to the Tibetan Institute of Performing Arts (TIPA), the road was lined with Tibetans and other well-wishers, waves of white silk scarves in their hands as the early morning sun illuminated their joyful, smiling faces.

Science, Ethics and Education - Second Day
March 25th 2015

Science, Ethics and Education - First Day
March 24th 2015

Addressing Conference on Strengthening Democracy in Asia and Members of the Gymkhana Club
March 23rd 2015

His Holiness the Dalai Lama Expresses Condolences over the Death of Lee Kuan Yew
March 23rd 2015

Explore